[@12Z8...DpYu](12Z8vWgQZSDhVXdvoUxpbdfcr9KDH2W3sypL42m9neJoDpYu-hydradx) another noobs comment , please dont comment more 

[@12Z8...DpYu](12Z8vWgQZSDhVXdvoUxpbdfcr9KDH2W3sypL42m9neJoDpYu-hydradx) If your grift involves dozens of hours per month commitment and adds layers of value to the community, you probably need a new grift. +10 points for the stupidest comment I've read on here in months. So stupid I've increased conviction.



I appreciate all Jose Crypto interactions on the communication channels.

However, I don't appreciate them enough to justify 510K HDX (again).

It's about community management. It's clear that Jose's English is not great, and sometimes leads to longer discussions than needed if the communication were more objective and well expressed.

I sum up Jose's interactions to the following:
- ~50% of the time is spent posting this:
>When providing liquidity in Omnipool, there are three possible outcomes based on the position's relationship with H2O (which acts as an index for all assets in the Omnipool):
>1.    If the position is above the entry price relative to H2O, you will likely receive H2O to partially cover impermanent loss (IL).
>2.    If the position is below the entry point relative to H2O, you may end up with less of the X token. In this case, you will not receive H2O, so you'll need to wait until the position is closer to your entry point. This is due to Omnipool's mechanism for socializing IL.
>3.    If the prices remain in the same range relative to H2O, your assets will be auto-compounded. For example, if you initially provide 100 DOT and later see 102 DOT, the extra 2 DOT are from fees. However, this depends on the trading volume of the asset.
>For more information, you can read about it on
>https://docs.hydration.net/products/trading/liquidity/impermanent_loss
- The other ~50% of the time, some community members answer first to user doubts (and receive no tip). Later, Jose appears and says "Yes, do what -some other user- said". I get it, it's a part-time job, but the point is that I don't see other useful community members getting tipped, yet they provide the same value as Jose (and sometimes with better English communication skills). Other times is the usual redirection to a Discord support ticket.

(take the percentages above with a great pinch of salt, they are there just to provide you the general sense)

I want this to be a constructive comment. I would enjoy having clearer metrics on how useful Jose really is. For example, I don't know how many user support tickets (on discord) Jose helped resolve. The time spent per week is mostly useless to me. One person can take 1 minute writing a two paragraphs answer, and another person takes 5 minutes (what if Jose is the person that takes 5 minutes, especially if it's in English?).

If I see clear signs of improvement (English skills, clearer and verifiable metrics to evaluate the effort not only measured in "time per week"), I would double down on the tip next time. I have voted Aye for the past ones, but since I didn't see any improvement to the points I've expressed, it's a Nay for me this time, thus I'm justifying it.

I just don't want this tip to become something that is almost taken for granted because everybody likes Jose. It should be backed by strong arguments too.



I think you get the point just by looking at the Tip Request title:
**"23 April - 13 August: 510,000 HDX- Comunnity Manneging -"**

Good enough is not enough.


[@1geB...qeJf](1geBdsCA3wnHYj6stwtnwynUZmQMuhdmfDxkQBzY2b8qeJf-hydradx) 

Thanks for commenting, sir. Well, Discord is recommended, as it has a ticket system where users can share all information privately and have everything in one place accessible to devs if necessary.

One can argue with what you've written, but it simply isn't the time it takes to respond. One has to be aware of and follow up on channels and tickets. Unfortunately, there isn't a specific hour where users are active; it could be at any time or day.

There will be issues that are resolved in a single response in a matter of minutes/seconds, and others require further investigation, which takes longer.

Even so, your point can be said to be valid.

In the time mentioned, around 340 tickets have been resolved, mostly by me, although some cases in the same ticket may have multiple questions, as they can be kept open for as long as necessary. 

Have good day 🙌

beneficiary

 23 April - 13 August: 510,000 HDX- Comunnity Manneging -

Use the Last 7 Days avg price from kraken : 0.0097
Avg hours per week in that time: 15h
16 weeks

Details: In the moderation of the community, I was present answering the doubts, Hydration groups, telegram and discord, on Tickets, or personals messages.

Thanks to the team for letting me be part of this great project, hope we continue to grow and progress.

Adress: 7NzNFJb2pfy2mZzdS2ky8okkXZL52fn2VAvAsc8jigvCtBec

assetKind

amount

validFrom

Executed

Submitted

DecisionDepositPlaced

DecisionStarted

ConfirmStarted

Confirmed

spender

Tip treasury - Jose Crypto- (April - August)

root

whitelisted_caller

referendum_canceller

referendum_killer

general_admin

treasurer

tipper

omnipool_admin

economic_parameters

Origin able to dispatch a whitelisted call.

 Origin for spending very high amounts of HDX(<= 50M HDX) from the treasury as well as generally administering it.

Origin able to spend up to 2,222,222 HDX from the treasury at once.

Origin able to spend up to 50K HDX from the treasury at once.

Origin able to perform specific Omnipool-related actions.